That’s Ent-ertainment
By gum, I think they’re really going to do it.
March 1st is the day that the application for a massive statue of an Ent goes before Birmingham City Council’s Planning Committee – and to my horror, the Planning Officer has recommended that it be approved.
If you don’t know what an Ent is – and I’ve found that most people I’ve spoken to don’t – you’re probably not a J R R Tolkien fan. The Ents are tree giants – here’s the Wikipedia definition.
It’s probably not very fashionable of me to say this, being from Moseley, but I’m really not a Tolkien fan either. I was a big reader when I was little, but I tried Lord of the Rings and found that it wasn’t my thing. I’ve never had the inclination to try since. And the film – oh yes, very pretty, but – I dunno – so gay!
So why an Ent? And what’s it got to do with Moseley?
Well, Tolkien’s family lived in and around Moseley when he was small, and it is said that parts of Moseley Bog and the surrounding Sarehole area inspired Middle Earth.
In fact, Tolkien and I grew up in the same place (give or take 100 yards), albeit 80 years apart. He and I played in the same parts of Moseley Bog as children (he knew it as “The Dell”, we called it “Blackhills”) and whether you’re into his fantasy world or not, it’s easy to see how he was inspired to create it.
It’s also easy to see why Moseley is proud of its connection to Tolkien. But I don’t think a statue of an Ent – let alone this design – is the best way of commemorating this.
Leaving aside the fact that we’re about to get a huge ugly metal statue of something only geeks have heard of, that looks like it’s been designed by a child, on the village green, what about the fact that it’s nowhere near any of the places that inspired the books? Why not put it in Moseley Bog, or by Edgbaston Reservoir? If you’re trying to attract Tolkien tourists, why not put more money into marketing the beautiful bog and mill? Put on tours to visit the two towers?
Don’t get me wrong – like many others I’m all for public art. But why weren’t any alternatives offered?
The meeting starts at 11 o’clock and the Ent statue is one of 16 applications under consideration.
UPDATE (Midday, 1st March)
No, I haven’t heard yet. But I just noticed that Eye on Moseley used the “That’s Ent-ertainment” headline 18 months ago. Bugger.
UPDATE (10pm, 1st March)
Yep – as suspected, it has been approved.



